ZICKLIN GRADUATE ACCOUNTING SOCIETY
  • Home
  • Upcoming Events
    • Registration
    • Event Policies
  • Past Events
    • Description
    • Photo Gallery
  • ZGAS Board
    • Executive Board
    • ZGAS Alumni
    • Become a Volunteer
  • About Us
    • Our Mission
    • Why Join ZGAS?
  • NEWSLETTER
    • Latest Issue
    • Subscribe to Newsletter

Sam Antar: The Perfect Criminal?

5/13/2015

5 Comments

 
By Derek Berezdivin

April 21, 2015: For a Baruch student and future auditor, the Crazy Eddie case is infamous. Over a decade, auditors, Wall Street and millions more were fooled by cousins Eddie and Sam Antar who ran Crazy Eddie from 1971-1987. As students, we learned about Crazy Eddie in multiple accounting classes; documentaries and innumerable case studies have been made about it as it was one of the greatest embarrassments to the accounting profession.

I have the distinct good fortune of being in the Zicklin Graduate Accounting Society – the ones that invited Sam Antar to Baruch College. As I was waiting for Mr. Antar to arrive and the event to begin in the campus’ main conference room, the ex-president of my club suddenly rushed by with a short, unfriendly and unassuming man. Though it seemed very hard to believe, this had to be the man that had perpetrated one of the largest frauds in American history.

After we spent some time awkwardly introducing ourselves and fumbling for cables to hook up his computer to the projector, we took him into a smaller room where a private lunch had been set up for members of ZGAS. Unabashedly, he sat down at the front of the room and declared that he would answer all our questions. Of the club members, I sat closest to him to help him feel welcome as well as to be able to engage him in conversation. From my angle, I felt he looked decidedly untrustworthy.

As soon as he opened his mouth, however, it was clear he was one of the most engaging, interesting and charming speakers I had ever encountered during my time at Baruch. Ethics don’t help at all, Mr. Antar told us. “I don’t subscribe to a code of ethics. A code of ethics only makes it easier for people like me to take advantage of you.”

Throughout the lunch and presentation, Mr. Antar was unrestrained about how he cheated millions. The crowd was enraptured. “Disarm with charm,” he repeated multiple times. “Appeal to vanity: flattery and compliments will get you everywhere.” One female student asked him how to he got people to like him. He responded, “you’re sexy” – demonstrating for us.

So how did Crazy Eddie fool the auditors for so many years? Simply put, they were experts on human behavior. “I have no problems lying,” he told us. “But distraction is better than a lie.” The demographics of the audit profession used to be made up of mostly single men. All they had to do was distract the auditors with attractive female employees. Mr. Antar took auditors to strip clubs and parties for the majority of their audit. Then, they would find themselves with lots of work to do and little time, rushing their decision-making. It wasn’t that the auditors were stupid, he told us. The auditors simply did not want to believe they were bad people.

Mr. Antar was adamant that he was not reformed. “The Feds don’t know I’m sleeping on a million dollars in my bedroom every night” he told me. I laughed, though a part of me is still unsure whether he was joking. “Don’t trust me? I might be cheating you all right now.” he said as we laughed.

Despite his warnings and reputation, I had a very difficult time believing such a charming man could be so malicious. I could identify with him. After all, why go through the effort of sharing how fraudsters take advantage of others? Why teach us the tricks of his trade? I started wondering if maybe this was just his character, his shtick, his way of showing us what a villain was like. Perhaps deep down he was actually a good guy that had gotten himself into a bad situation. Thinking I might catch him in this apparent paradox, I asked him why he bothered explaining himself. “I like to brag about my accomplishments,” he said. “Is this true?” I pushed. “Yes,” he replied without a second thought.

Crazy Eddie managed to fool auditors for more than a decade. They fooled Wall Street and many investors as well, managing to take their company public and making millions. The cause of their undoing? A hedge fund manager, believing in the integrity of Crazy Eddie’s financial statements, thought he could acquire the company cheaply. Within two months of having acquired it, the manager realized the millions of claimed inventory were nonexistent; Crazy Eddie came crashing down.

“Who here can claim that they have not lied today?” he asked us. Uncertain, I did not raise my hand, but neither did anybody else. I was shocked; these were the accounting hopefuls of the future. It was only noon. Had everybody really lied? How could nobody be willing to hold themselves as an honest person in front of their peers? Was I so naïve to not realize that people lie so often?

It’s human nature, he said. According to Mr. Antar, 80% of people are situationally ethical, whereas only 10% are always either ethical or unethical. Clearly, none of us are really as good as we like to believe. The way Mr. Antar worked the room quickly exposed all of our attraction to power. Are these grim forebodings for those pursuing careers in the field of accounting?

Surprisingly, it was Mr. Antar himself with an answer to this question. We need to increase whistleblower protections and bounties. Nearly 40% of frauds are discovered from tips, as opposed to external or internal audits (as common sense might have you believe). “The state of education is fantasy-land,” says Mr. Antar. “An audit shouldn’t be called an audit, it’s really just a review.” We should be more realistic about accepting human nature and realizing that the AICPA’s, and even society’s, code of ethics is often bent or broken. According to Mr. Antar, it takes a villain like him to expose these issues and give us all a reality-check.

At the end of the event, my accounting club took a picture with Mr. Antar. As we took it, he joked how one of the benefits of these pictures was being able to take them near young, attractive women – causing them to giggle. I continued to refuse to believe he was really so bad, despite his warnings and the evidence to the contrary. I left the event believing I just witnessed something incredible. Two weeks later, though, the only question on my mind is: is he the perfect criminal?

5 Comments
Gabriela
5/14/2015 07:22:07 am

Interesting! Nice job.

I get it when he says it's the human nature, but I think there's a huge difference between be aware of evil or selfishness,and the decisions we make about it.
Anyway, there will always be a debate about admiring criminals and it's worth to do it.

Reply
Claudia Dreifus
5/14/2015 08:13:34 am

Fascinating story, Derek.

Reply
Nick Hsu link
6/2/2015 05:42:38 am

Glad you did it! Its a great article!

Reply
Kathleen
6/2/2015 09:19:50 am

Nice article. You captured a lot of my thoughts about Mr. Antar. FYI, I was sort of stunned by his question if anyone had not yet lied. I seriously doubt most of us had lied that day. I think many of us were just taken aback by his certainty and were searching our minds to see where we could have lied that day.

Reply
Sam
6/16/2015 08:07:45 pm

Sorry but I feel its highly inappropriate to bring in such a man like a celebrity of some sort into an educational institution committed to integrity. He belongs at a Jerry Spring show not Baruch College.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    ZGAS

    Hello ZGAS Members,
    We have created this to give you an opportunity to express yourself. Be it a suggestion, idea or even a question, just go ahead!

    Archives

    April 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    June 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    November 2011
    October 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    November 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010

    Categories

    All
    Becker
    Derivatives
    Events
    Ifrs
    Internship/Job
    Ocr
    Zgas

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Upcoming Events
    • Registration
    • Event Policies
  • Past Events
    • Description
    • Photo Gallery
  • ZGAS Board
    • Executive Board
    • ZGAS Alumni
    • Become a Volunteer
  • About Us
    • Our Mission
    • Why Join ZGAS?
  • NEWSLETTER
    • Latest Issue
    • Subscribe to Newsletter